Symfony Forms and Radar – Part 1

I explore how to integrate the Symfony Form Component with Radar.

I have several projects I’d like to build soon. One thing they have in common is there will be a lot of data entry via forms. Back in the day I used to use HTML_QuickForm but I haven’t used it for a long time.

For my projects at work, one uses a custom solution I built and the other uses AngularJS. I figured it was time to look around and find a current solution.

The two I came across was Symfony Form Component and Zend\Form. I’ve used many Symfony components so I figured I’d start with theirs.

I really dig Radar but I know that not everything easily fits in the Action-Domain-Responder model.

I leveraged the Symfony Forms documentation and webmozart/standalone-forms to create my proof of concept.

Configuring a Symfony Form

I managed to get it to work but it’s not ideal (yet). To see my first proof of concept check out futureproofphp/symfony-forms-radar.

The first caveat that I want to express is that I wanted to leverage as much of what Symfony Forms has to offer much of which is optional. My final solution may omit parts of this.

The first issue I found was with having to use multiple setters to build objects.

Symfony Translation Component uses addLoader and addResource to be configured correctly. FormFactoryBuilder and Twig_Environment use addExtension.

Aura.Di doesn’t really handle this use case. You can define a single parameter to be passed to the setter method. The was around this is with the two pass system. In a ContainerConfig you have two methods, define and modify. The first part define is where you define all of your dependencies. You should not be instantiating anything in this method other than LazyInterface objects. The second part modify actually takes an instantiated object from the container and further modifies it. Ideally, you’d do as much as possible in define so you’re not instantiating objects that you’re not actually using.

I was able to work around this using two strategies.

The first was to find or create setters that can take an array of objects instead of having to call the single method multiple times in the container. FormFactoryBuilder already has addExtensions that I can use, but Translator needed to be extended so I could have addLoaders and addResources methods. Twig_Extension has setExtensions but I was unable to use that (I’ll explain why later).

The only issue with this strategy was that if I included LazyInterface objects in an array, they didn’t get resolved when the setter was called.

This leads to my second strategy which was the creation of a new LazyInterface class LazyArray which takes an array as a parameter and resolves any LazyInterface objects within it, returning an array with the resolved objects.

Now, why wasn’t I able to use the setExtensions method from Twig_Environment? Circular dependencies.

The Twig_Environment extension FormExtension requires a TwigRenderer which requires a TwigRendererEngine which requires the Twig_Environment. Aura.di can’t resolve this.

The way around it is either to not use that extension, or to configure the Twig_Environment extensions in modify. I chose the second option.


After more digging, I found that calling setEnvironment on the TwigRendererEngine is not required. I had done it because that’s how it was done in the webmozart tutorial but then I noticed that setEnvironment is called from FormExtension::initRuntime. This makes sense because since it’s a Twig extension, shouldn’t it already know the Twig_Environment?

Once I removed this setter from the container, I was able to move the configuration of Twig extensions back into define.

Using the Form

Now that I got everything configured in the ContainerConfig I need to use the form I created. The issue I quickly ran into is that a single form does a whole lot of stuff.

First, the form handles the request. By default, it pulls data out of $_POST but can be configured via an extension to take an HTTP Foundation Request object.

Then, the form validates this input and will return the filtered/sanitized output via the getData method.

Lastly, through the Twig the form is rendered, prepopulated with data and any validation errors.

If you’re not familiar with Radar check out my post Radar Under the Hood where it talked in depth how it works.

The problem here is that the whole point of Radar is to separate your concerns.

For my form to work, I create the form in the input and call handleRequest. I return the form so it’s passed on to the domain.

In the domain, I’d check if the form was valid and potentially do something with the data. I return the form as the payload for the responder.

In the responder, I render the form in twig template and return the PSR-7 Response.

I don’t like that I need to have a single form object that’s passed through all three layers just to render a form.

Ideally, it would work more like this.

In the input, I’d pull out the values from the PSR-7 Request and return an array or domain request object with the data.

In the domain, I’d validate the data from the input and do something with the data if valid. I’d return a domain response to the responder that contained the filtered/sanitized data and any validation error messages I generated.

In the responder, I’d take the domain response and feed it into a form object that is then passed into a twig template for rendering. I’d return the PSR-7 Response.


I haven’t given up on this yet (hence the “Part 1” in the title of this post).

My next step is to look at the components and extensions being used in my proof of concept and see what they are doing and if there are ways to pull them apart.

For instance, I’m creating a Validation object that gets passed into the form via the ValidationExtension. I’m assuming I can define my validation separately, but I’ll have to research how to assign validation error messages to the form externally.

If validation is separate, I can probably pass in an array of data to be validated, instead of having the validator pull data directly from the request.

However, this post is already very long, so I’ll save the rest for Part 2.

Author: Andrew Shell

Madison, WI developer, Co-Founder and CTO of Pinpoint Software, founder of Madison PHP.